The first few weeks of NFL games have been officiated by replacements, as the Referees Union is taking part in a labor hold out over a
$16 million pay increase. League officials' decision to not agree to the increase is, for all intents and purposes, a matter of principle. In the grand scheme of the NFL, $16 million, covered by 32 teams over the span of 5 years is...not that much money.
The Players Union has issued a
letter of support of the strike, and there exists the tip of a
legal hook of the league's responsibility to maintain safe working conditions for players. Still, talk of players holding out their labor in solidarity has been that, just talk. As well, the players are in an interesting bind, such that the more they complain about the officiating, the more leverage the league has against the ref's union. The real issue is not the officiating (as...erratic as it's been), it's the league's handling of the labor strike that is the issue. Players know this, so for the most part their rhetoric of solidarity has less focused on complaining about the replacements, and more focused on getting the league to agree to the Referees Union's demands.
From what I've seen, fans are mostly focused on the quality of calls. For sure, players are still playing, but there has been no shortage of controversial calls that might
try the patience of more dedicated fans. Still, lest we loose site of the bigger picture, only one team can win the game. As a fan of the game (my last team loyalty left Philly with Randall Cunningham), what I most want is for everybody to do their best and for nobody to get hurt.
Ironically, I think this is the same thing the owners and league officials want. So long as their so-called "product" (arghh!) still sells–to the public and advertisers–they will be fine with locking out the Refs Union. Their thinking is, so what if there's a missed call or two? Are people watching? Are we selling advertisements? Then line 'em up!
At this point, the technology exists to all but do away with the human error of officiating (I can't be the first one to have thought of this, right? I mean, we already have a
Megatron in the league). Put that in your Hegel machine and press play. Where is the real dichotomy? team vs. team? players vs. refs? fans vs. the game? or labor vs. capital?